Many of the credit card offers that appear on this site are from credit card companies from which we receive financial compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). However, the credit card information that we publish has been written and evaluated by experts who know these products inside out. We only recommend products we either use ourselves or endorse. This site does not include all credit card companies or all available credit card offers that are on the market. See our advertising policy here where we list advertisers that we work with, and how we make money. You can also review our credit card rating methodology.
Christine ran her own business developing and managing insurance and financial services. This stoked a passion for points and miles and she now has over 2 dozen credit cards and creates in-depth, deta...
With years of experience in corporate marketing and as the Executive Director of the American Chamber of Commerce in Qatar, Keri is now Editor-in-Chief at UP, overseeing daily content operations and r...
Juan has been involved in credit cards, loyalty, travel, and personal finance for more than 10 years. He has worked for several outlets including The Points Guy and Forbes and was previously Editor-in...
We may be compensated when you click on product links, such as credit cards, from one or more of our advertising partners. Terms apply to the offers below. See our Advertising Policy for more about our partners, how we make money, and our rating methodology. Opinions and recommendations are ours alone.
Most of us make purchases every single day. It’s not uncommon to take a trip to the grocery store, pick up a prescription at the drugstore, fill up the car with gas, and then order pizza for dinner. And, if you have a family, chances are those purchases are just the beginning.
Having a credit card that earns rewards on common daily expenses can be a smart financial move, especially if those points could help you offset the cost of a nice annual vacation or weekend getaway.
On the agenda today are 2 very popular rewards-earning cards, the American Express® Gold Card and the Citi Premier® Card. Both cards have the potential to be at the top of your wallet for everyday spending.
We’ll help you decide what card is better for you by comparing how you earn rewards on each card, the options you’ll have when it’s time to redeem those rewards, and all the additional benefits and protections that come with each card.
Amex Gold Card vs. Citi Premier Card — Overview
Here’s a quick summary of all the key features and benefits that come with the Amex Gold card and the Citi Premier card. Details of each benefit will be explained more thoroughly later in the story.
Earn 60,000 points when you spend $4,000 on purchases in the first 6 months.
Earn 60,000 points after spending $4,000 in purchases within the first 3 months. Plus, for a limited time, earn a total of 10 points per $1 spent on hotel, car rentals, and attractions (excluding air travel) booked on the Citi Travel portal through June 30, 2024.
Earning
4x points at U.S. supermarkets (limit of $25,000 per calendar year) and restaurants worldwide, plus takeout and delivery in the U.S.
3x points on flights purchased directly from the airlines or via Amex Travel
1x points on all other eligible purchases
3x points on air travel, hotels, supermarkets, gas stations and at restaurants
1x points on all other purchases
Top Redemption Options
Redeem points for select travel via Amex Travel
Transfer points to airline and hotel partners
Statement credits, gift cards, shopping with retail partners, charitable donations
Redeem points for select travel via ThankYou.com
Transfer points to airline and hotel partners
Statement credits, gift cards, shopping with retail partners, charitable donations, cash
Travel Benefits and Protections
Secondary car rental insurance; trip delay insurance; baggage insurance
No foreign transaction fees
Up to $100 hotel credit
No foreign transaction fees
Shopping Benefits and Protections
Up to $10 monthly statement credit at select dining partners
Up to $120 in annual Uber Cash: get $10 monthly in Uber Cash for Uber Eats orders or Uber rides in the U.S. when you add your Gold Card to your Uber account
Authorized Users: no charge for up to 5 additional users, $35 for each user added after that (rates and fees)
Annual fee of $95
Authorized Users: $0
Requirements
Good to excellent credit score (670 to 850)
The Value of a Welcome Offer
Welcome offers provide the opportunity for cardholders to earn a lump sum of rewards within the first months after card approval. Fortunately, after being approved and meeting the minimum spending requirements, you’ll earn a generous welcome offer with either the Amex Gold card or Citi Premier card.
Welcome offers change constantly, so be sure to check the most recent offer before applying for any card.
Bottom Line: Both the Amex Gold card and Citi Premier card come with generous welcome offers that are generally worth more than $1,000 when redeemed for travel.
Membership Rewards Points vs. Citi ThankYou Points
The Amex Gold card earns Membership Rewards points and the Citi Premier card earns ThankYou Points. The 2 cards have somewhat similar points-earning structures and redemption options.
However, depending on your spending mix and redemption preferences, one card may be a better choice for you than the other.
Let’s review what you can expect regarding points-earning and redemption options on our 2 featured cards.
Earning Potential
If you’re selecting a card to use for everyday purchases, you’ll want to pay close attention to a card’s bonus points-earning categories as they can help you rack up rewards quickly.
Here’s how the Amex Gold card and Citi Premier card earn rewards on every purchase and which categories have bonus earnings.
Earning Category
Amex Gold Card
Citi Premier Card
Travel
3x points per dollar on flights purchased directly from the airlines or via Amex Travel
2x points per dollar on other select travel via Amex Travel
3x points per dollar on air travel and hotels
Additional Bonus Earning Categories
4x points per dollar at U.S. supermarkets (limit of $25,000 in purchases per calendar year, then 1x points)
4x points per dollar at restaurants worldwide, plus takeout and delivery in the U.S.
3x points per dollar at supermarkets, gas stations, and restaurants
All Other Purchases
1x points per dollar
1x points per dollar
Earning Example
Different spending mixes result in different levels of earned rewards. Here’s an example of how rewards are earned on each of our featured cards.
Let’s say you spend the following each year:
$10,000 on flights purchased with the airline or the card’s travel portal
$18,000 on groceries
$5,000 on gas
$3,000 dining out
Here’s how your earnings would play out on the Amex Gold card and on the Citi Premier card:
Amex Gold Card
3x points on $10,000 of flights = 30,000 points
4x points on $18,000 of groceries = 72,000 points
1x points on $5,000 of gas = 5,000 points
4x points on $3,000 of dining out = 12,000 points
Total: 119,000 points x 2.2 cents = $2,618 in value when redeemed for travel via the card’s transfer partners
Citi Premier Card
3x points on $10,000 of flights = 30,000 points
3x points on $18,000 of groceries = 54,000 points
3x points on $5,000 of gas = 15,000 points
3x points on $3,000 of dining out = 9,000 points
Total: 108,000 points x 1.6 cents = $1,728 in value when redeemed for travel via the card’s transfer partners
Of course, this example is arbitrary as your spending mix will differ, plus how you actually redeem your rewards will determine the value you’ll receive. The example is meant to illustrate how the same spending mix can result in different earnings depending on the card you use.
You’ll want to evaluate your spending habits and match them to each card’s bonus-earning categories to determine the best option for you.
Bottom Line: Both the Amex Gold card and Citi Premier card have robust earning structures for everyday purchases and travel. The better card for you will depend on your spending mix and how it matches the card’s bonus category earnings. If your greatest household expense is gas, for example, you may find the Citi Premier card is a better fit since it earns 3x points on gas, compared to the Amex Gold card which earns only 1x points for the same purchases.
Redemption Options
Once you’ve accumulated a nice stash of rewards, you’ll want to receive the best value when redeeming your points. While you’ll often realize the most value when transferring points to travel partners, you will still have several other ways to use your points.
Here are the choices you’ll have for redeeming points earned on the Amex Gold card or the Citi Premier card:
Redemption Option
Amex Gold Card
Citi Premier Card
Travel
Redeem points for flights for 1 cent each via Amex Travel
Gift cards, shopping with partners such as Amazon and Uber (point value varies)
Airline seat upgrades
Charitable donation
Statement credits and cash (points worth 1 cent each)
Gift cards, shopping at retail partners (point value varies)
Transfer to Sears Shop Your Way
Charitable donation
While Membership Rewards Points and Citi ThankYou Points can normally be redeemed through the cards’ respective travel portals for 1 cent each, greater value can be had by transferring points to airline or hotel partners.
The Amex Gold card allows you to transfer Membership Rewards points to airline and hotel partners, most at a 1:1 ratio. You could also redeem points for flights or stays with The Hotel Collection or Fine Hotels & Resorts at the rate of 1 cent each via Amex Travel. Other eligible travel can be booked via the portal at the rate of just 0.7 cents for each point. You can also redeem points to bid on airline seat upgrades.
Note that redeeming Membership Rewards points for gift cards, shopping, or statement credits could result in a value of less than 1 cent per point.
Citi ThankYou Points can be redeemed for travel for 1 cent each through ThankYou.com or transferred to airline and hotel partners for even greater potential value.
ThankYou Points can also be transferred to the Sears Shop Your Way program where it’s possible to find some decent gift card redemptions or use points to shop at Sears and Kmart.
Membership Rewards points cannot be redeemed for cash while ThankYou Points can be redeemed for cash at a value of 1 cent each.
Examples of Transfer Redemptions
Amex Gold Card
While you’ll have several redemption options, the best value for your Membership Rewards points will be realized by transferring to the Amex airline partners.
JetBlue, Singapore Airlines, and ANA are just a few of Amex’s airline transfer partners, but here’s how you can use your Amex points for big value on a bucket-list trip.
Fly Qatar Airways Qsuites From the U.S. to Doha — Transfer Membership Rewards points to British Airways Executive Club and use Avios to book a one-way Qatar Airways business class award ticket starting at 70,000 Avios plus taxes and fees. This flight normally costs thousands of dollars.
Fly ANA Business Class From the U.S. to Japan — Transfer Membership Rewards points to ANA Mileage Club and book a flight in ANA business class from the U.S. to Japan, with round-trip rates starting at just 75,000 miles, plus taxes and fees.
To learn more about the best way to maximize Membership Rewards transfer partners, read our story where we list dozens of examples on how to get the most value out of your Amex points.
The Citi Premier card earns ThankYou Points that can be transferred to many popular airline partners at a 1:1 ratio and a couple of hotel partners. Transfer partners include Air France-KLM Flying Blue, EVA Air, and Turkish Airlines, just to name a few.
Fly Singapore Suites to Europe — Transfer ThankYou Points to Singapore Airlines’ Krisflyer program and enjoy first class luxury in your A380 suite from New York to Frankfurt. Prices start at 97,000 miles for Saver awards.
Fly a Family of 4 to Hawaii on United — Transfer just 60,000 ThankYou Points to Turkish Airlines to book 4 round-trip tickets from the mainland U.S. to the Hawaiian Islands on United Airlines.
Hot Tip: The best time to transfer Membership Rewards points or ThankYou Points is during a transfer bonus promotion. Log in to your card account and under the redemption section, select the transfer option to see if there are offers available. Examples of past transfer bonuses include a 30% bonus when transferring Membership Rewards points to Marriott Bonvoy or a 25% bonus when transferring Citi ThankYou Points to JetBlue.
Travel Benefits and Protections
Travel benefits can save you money on travel-related purchases, provide assistance during your trips, and should something go wrong, you may have travel insurance that can reimburse you for covered expenses.
Here are the travel benefits and protections that come with both the Amex Gold card and the Citi Premier card:
Hotel Program Benefits — Both the Amex Gold card and Citi Premier card offer elite-style benefits through their associated hotel programs when you use your card to book your stay.
No Foreign Transaction Fees — Use your card when you travel internationally as neither card charges foreign transaction fees.
Amex Gold Card
The Hotel Collection Elite-style Benefits — Use your card to book a 2-night stay or longer with The Hotel Collection and receive room upgrades when available, $100 on-site amenities, and daily breakfast for 2. Pay with points or earn 2x points per dollar when you pay with your card.
Car Rental Program Discounts and Benefits — Enjoy Amex discounts and benefits at Hertz, Avis, and Alamo.
Car Rental Insurance — Use your card to reserve and pay for your car rental, decline the rental agency’s CDW/LDW coverage, and receive secondary coverage for damage and theft. Card members also have access to Premium Protection for 1 low price that covers the entire rental period (up to 41 days).
Trip Delay Insurance — If your trip is delayed for more than 12 hours for a covered reason, you could receive up to $300 in reimbursement for incidental expenses.
Baggage Insurance — Use your card to pay for your common carrier ticket and receive coverage for lost, stolen, or damaged luggage, up to $1,250 for carry-on and $500 for checked bags.
Global Assist Hotline — When you’re traveling more than 100 miles from home, have access 24/7 to help to arrange emergency transportation, receive medical or legal referrals, assist with a lost passport, and more.
Citi Premier Card
$100 Hotel Credit — Book a hotel of $500 or more for a single stay (excluding taxes and fees) via ThankYou.com using your card and receive an annual statement credit of $100.
Mastercard Travel Benefits — The Citi Premier card is a World Elite Mastercard offering lifestyle benefits such as hotel elite-style benefits via the Mastercard Luxury Hotel & Resorts Portfolio program, Priceless Experiences, car rental discounts, and more.
Bottom Line: While neither the Amex Gold card nor the Citi Premier card is packed with travel benefits and protections, the Amex Gold card is superior in this category due to the available car rental protection, trip delay insurance, and baggage insurance you won’t find on the Citi Premier card.
Shopping Benefits and Protections
Both the Amex Gold card and Citi Premier card come with core protection coverages for eligible items purchased with either card.
Purchase Protection — The Amex Gold card provides coverage for theft or damage for 90 days after the purchase date for eligible items purchased with the card. Coverage is limited to $10,000 per covered item, up to $50,000 per event. The Citi Premier card offers protection for 90 days from the date of purchase, up to $10,000 per incident, and $50,000 per calendar year.
Extended Warranty — The Amex Gold card will add 1 additional year of warranty to eligible items, purchased with the card, that have manufacturer’s warranties of 5 years or less. The Citi Premier card provides up to an additional 24 months extended warranty, for a total of no more than 7 total years including the manufacturer’s warranty, for eligible items purchased in part or entirely with the card.
In addition to these protections, each card has its own shopping benefits and protections.
Amex Gold Card
Monthly Dining Credit — Receive up to $10 in dining credits each month, up to $120 each year, when you enroll your card and use it for purchases at Grubhub, The Cheesecake Factory, Goldbelly, Wine.com, Milk Bar, and select Shake Shack locations.
Monthly Uber Cash — Add your Amex Gold card as a payment option to your Uber account and receive $10 in Uber Cash each month, up to $120 each year. Uber Cash can be used for Uber rides and Uber Eats in the U.S.
ShopRunner Membership — Receive free 2-day shipping and returns plus discounts at dozens of retailers with your complimentary ShopRunner membership.
Amex Offers — Login to your online card account and select from dozens of offers from select retailers and service providers. Use your card to make the associated purchases to earn additional Membership Rewards points or cash-back.
Citi Premier Card
Citi Merchant Offers — Citi Merchant Offers have become more robust lately. Examples of recent offers include 10% back at Shell gas stations, 5% back at Sam’s Club, and 1.5% back at CVS. You’ll find dozens of offers by logging into your online card account and adding the offer to your card. Make the required purchase and you’ll earn cash-back in addition to any applicable ThankYou Points.
Mastercard Shopping Benefits — Receive complimentary ShopRunner membership that comes with free 2-day shipping and returns, plus discounts at dozens of retailers. You’ll also receive a 3-month trial DoorDash membership, discounts at Lyft and Fandango, and more.
Please keep in mind that all of these benefit and protection descriptions have been abbreviated and do not include any terms and conditions that may apply. Each card’s Guide to Benefits should be your reference for full descriptions, additional benefits/protections that may be available, and any terms and conditions that apply.
Bottom Line: Both the Amex Gold card and Citi Premier card come with shopping benefits and protections such as complimentary ShopRunner membership, purchase protection, and extended warranty coverage. Additionally, the Amex Gold card offers monthly statement credits for select dining purchases, Uber Cash, and Amex Offers. The Citi Premier card comes with Citi Merchant Offers and the Mastercard shopping benefits of a trial DoorDash membership and discounts on Lyft, Fandango, and more.
Annual Fees and Authorized Users
It’s important to acknowledge the cost of holding a credit card in order to determine the net value you’ll actually receive. You’ll want to make sure you receive at least enough value from your card to offset its associated annual fee.
The Amex Gold card charges an annual fee of $250, while the Citi Premier card charges an annual fee of $95.
The Amex Gold card does not charge a fee to add up to 5 authorized users. Each additional user after that incurs a $35 charge. There is no charge to add authorized users to the Citi Premier card.
Credit Score Requirements
You will need a good to excellent credit score, normally 670 to 850, to qualify for either the Amex Gold card or Citi Premier card.
Final Thoughts
For earning rewards on common everyday purchases and travel, both the Amex Gold card and Citi Premier card suit that purpose perfectly with their robust points-earning structures.
The Amex Gold card, however, offers better travel benefits such as having access to Premium Protection car rental insurance for 1 low price that covers the entire rental period, trip delay insurance, and baggage delay insurance. If you don’t have another travel rewards credit card with premium travel benefits, the Citi Premier card may not be a good stand-alone choice as your primary card for travel purchases.
If travel benefits are not a priority, consider the Amex Gold card’s Uber and dining credits, which can help offset the $250 annual fee. The Citi Premier doesn’t have as many shopping benefits, but it does have a $100 hotel credit which can offset its $95 annual fee.
Either card could work well to earn you a ton of flexible points which you be redeemed in a variety of ways. Before you make a final decision, though, analyze your spending habits to see which card would earn you the most points. Then, ask yourself how you’d like to use your points and see which card’s redemption options best align with your preferences.
For the car rental collision damage coverage benefit of the American Express® Gold Card, eligibility and benefit level varies by card. Terms, conditions and limitations apply. Visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by AMEX Assurance Company. Car rental loss or damage coverage is offered through American Express Travel Related Services Company, Inc. For the baggage insurance plan benefit of the American Express® Gold Card, eligibility and benefit level varies by card. Terms, conditions and limitations apply. Visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by AMEX Assurance Company. For the purchase protection and extended warranty benefits of the American Express® Gold Card, eligibility and benefit level varies by card. Terms, conditions and limitations apply. Visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by AMEX Assurance Company. For the trip delay insurance benefits of the American Express Gold Card, eligibility and benefit level varies by card. Terms, conditions and limitations apply. Visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by New Hampshire Insurance Company, an AIG Company. For the Global Assist Hotline benefit of American Express Gold Card, eligibility and benefit level varies by card. Terms, conditions and limitations apply. Visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Card members may be responsible for the costs charged by third-party service providers.
The information regarding the For the rates and fees of the American Express Gold Card was independently collected by Upgraded Points and not provided nor reviewed by the issuer.
For rates and fees of the American Express® Gold Card, click here. For rates and fees of The Platinum Card® from American Express, click here.
Featured Image Credit: Upgraded Points
Frequently Asked Questions
Both cards function well as everyday spending cards. The Amex Gold card has the edge with travel and shopping benefits and protections. However, the Citi Premier card comes with a lower annual fee of $95 while the Amex Gold card charges $250.
The better card for you will be the one that most closely matches your spending mix and provides benefits relevant to your own lifestyle.
Yes, it can be. The Amex Gold card requires a good to excellent credit score, generally 670 to 850, to qualify. You’re more likely to get approved, however, if you have a score of 700 or higher.
Yes, you can redeem ThankYou Points for cash for a value of 1 cent each. However, you can receive greater potential value for your points when transferring to airline or hotel partners for award flights or free hotel nights.
The Citi Premier card does not come with car rental insurance.
Christine ran her own business developing and managing insurance and financial services. This stoked a passion for points and miles and she now has over 2 dozen credit cards and creates in-depth, detailed content for UP.
Disclaimer: Any comments listed below are not from the bank advertiser, nor have they been reviewed or approved by them. No responsibility will be taken by the bank advertiser for these comments.
0 comments
Any thoughts or questions? Comment below!
Email needed if you'd like comment updates. It will NOT be published.
0 comments
Any thoughts or questions? Comment below!
Email needed if you'd like comment updates. It will NOT be published.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.